Alex Cohen is the Director of Learning and Evaluation for the Richard M. Fairbanks Foundation.


Smoking remains the number one preventable cause of death in the United States, and Indiana’s smoking rate continues to rank among the worst in the nation. Smoking kills more than 11,000 Hoosiers each year. These impacts are felt especially hard among low-income individuals on Medicaid, who are more likely to be smokers.

In addition to the public health impacts, smoking also hurts Hoosiers through high taxpayer-funded costs. For example, Medicaid smokers in Indiana cost $540 million more each year than non-smokers, according to a study we released earlier this year. These lost resources could instead be put toward funding programs to address important issues like health, education or economic development.

One approach to lowering smoking rates, particularly among Medicaid beneficiaries, is to increase the use of evidence-based smoking cessation treatment. In addition to counseling, this includes medications designed to reduce the urge to smoke. Though smoking is a notoriously difficult habit to kick, these medications, known as nicotine-replacement therapy (or NRT), have been shown through several randomized controlled trials to increase quit rates.

When Massachusetts implemented a plan to expand access to evidence-based cessation treatment among low-income smokers, they saw a significant drop in smoking rates and improvements in health. They also saw reductions in healthcare costs to the tune of more than $3 saved for every $1 spent overall and more than $2 saved for every $1 spent for Medicaid alone.

In Indiana, Medicaid provides extensive coverage for both cessation counseling and medication. But while this is a critical first step, expanded coverage only matters if smokers actually take advantage of it and use these treatments.

Roughly 70% of Medicaid smokers report that they want to quit smoking. However, when we analyzed the data, we estimated that only 21% of Indiana smokers on Medicaid are using NRT.

This figure underscores a clear need for efforts—addressed to both patients and their providers, including doctors and dentists —that increase uptake of evidence-based smoking cessation treatment. This has the potential to both save money that could be better spent and, most importantly, save lives and improve health outcomes in Indiana.

Notes on calculations: Share of Indiana smokers using nicotine-replacement therapy comes from taking the estimated number of prescriptions for NRT among Indiana Medicaid beneficiaries, dividing it by the estimated number of prescriptions per person and dividing the result by the number of Medicaid beneficiaries who smoke. This approach to estimating utilization of NRT follows Ku et al. (2016) “Medicaid Tobacco Cessation: Big Gaps Remain in Efforts to Get Smokers to Quit.” Number of prescriptions comes from State Drug Utilization Data from Medicaid.gov for the fourth quarter of 2015 through the third quarter of 2016, which is the most recent data available. I adjust for the fact that bupropion is prescribed for both smoking cessation as well as other purposes based on the adjustment made by Ku et al. (2016). Number of prescriptions per person is estimated to be 2, also following Ku et al. (2016). Number of Medicaid beneficiaries who smoke is calculated by multiplying the number of Medicaid beneficiaries age 18 and older by the smoking rate among Medicaid beneficiaries in the United States.

Additional Posts

Compelling Lessons From Three Reports Provide Guidance for Addressing Substance Use Disorder, and Are More Relevant Than Ever as We Grapple With COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic and its associated challenges should cause us to redouble community efforts to address both unfamiliar and ongoing problems related to SUD in Marion County.

Indiana leaders form coalition to build, grow youth apprenticeship

More than 100 Indiana leaders, including corporate CEOs, university presidents, K-12 superintendents and state government officials, have joined a coalition to develop a statewide modern youth apprenticeship system.