COVID-19 pandemic could widen disparities as tax revenues take hit, report warns.
INDIANAPOLIS (October 1, 2020) —School-funding changes over the last decade have exacerbated inequities in how Indiana funds public schools. Students from low-income communities and public charter school students receive less than their fair share. Funding for students with disabilities and English language learners also is insufficient to meet their needs.
These findings are captured in a report released today by the Center on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE), a nonpartisan research organization at the University of Washington Bothell, and commissioned by the Richard M. Fairbanks Foundation. It offers a comprehensive look at Indiana’s school funding since 2008 property tax reforms and warns that school funding inequities could be compounded by COVID-19, which has hurt the state’s economy and diminished tax revenues.
“The consequence of these funding inequities is that where a child lives in Indiana, how much money the child’s family earns, and what type of public school a child chooses to attend increasingly determine how much public funding the child’s school receives,” said Claire Fiddian-Green, president and CEO of the Richard M. Fairbanks Foundation. “No one intended for this to happen, but these are challenges we must address to ensure that all public school students in Indiana – regardless of the type or location of the school they attend – can access the quality education they deserve.”
Students of color are disproportionately impacted by these funding gaps. On average statewide, per-pupil funding for schools where at least three-fourths of students are white is 18% higher than per-pupil funding for schools where less than one-fourth of students are white. This is driven largely by the funding disparities between traditional public schools and public charter schools, which serve mostly students of color and receive significantly less funding, since they receive only state funds and not local property tax dollars.
The report also examines Indiana’s special education funding and funding for English language learners. Findings show Indiana public schools are severely underfunded for their obligation to serve all students with disabilities appropriately, and English learners receive less than what federal benchmarks suggest is necessary to support their needs.
Two primary funding changes have contributed to these outcomes. Like most states, Indiana grants schools additional dollars to serve low-income students because more resources are required to support them. In 2015, the state changed the formula for how it allocates these additional dollars, resulting in a 35% drop in additional per-pupil funding for low-income students.
Changes related to property tax reform have also widened public school spending based on community income and school type. Since the state capped local property tax rates in 2008, school districts have launched 188 referenda to raise additional operating dollars. As wealthy districts increasingly gain voter approval for referenda, lower-income districts have been unable to raise those revenues and charter schools cannot access local referenda dollars. As a result, the spending gap between the wealthiest and poorest schools and districts has grown from 38% to 53% over the past decade.
“Put a different way, the disparity in education spending between the wealthiest and poorest school systems was about $4,700 per pupil in fiscal year 2017 – enough to hire an additional 33 teachers at a 500-student school,” said Ben Kleban, who authored the CRPE report.
Charter schools receive about $2,000 less per pupil than traditional public schools, despite serving a much higher share of students from low-income families – 75% compared to 48%.
“We believe that all students, regardless of family income, race or other characteristics, deserve an equal opportunity to thrive,” said Scott Bess, head of schools at Purdue Polytechnic High School, a school network that includes two public charter schools in Indianapolis and a third in South Bend. “Our hope is that the school funding realities in Indiana can change to reflect that ideal.”
To address Indiana’s funding inequities, the report recommends four key changes:
- Differentiate state aid based on local wealth: Under the current funding system, all districts or schools receive the same amount of basic state funding, regardless of their ability to generate or access local property tax revenues. Opportunities should be identified to differentiate state aid based on local wealth.
- Grant more equitable funding for low-income students and English language learners: Indiana falls far short of many other states across the country, as well as best practices supported by research, in the level of additional funding it provides to students from low-income households and for English language learners. To address this, Indiana should change its funding formula to grant additional funds for low-income students and begin to include English language learners in the formula, ensuring more funding for these students.
- Create a fairer system for special education funding: Indiana’s current method for funding special education students uses three broad categories to differentiate between lower- and higher-needs students with disabilities in K-12. This fails to account for the wide differences in needs among these groups and should be addressed. In addition, the magnitude of the weights falls short of other states and localities in all funding categories. The weights for students with the highest needs should be increased to properly account for the costs to serve these students.
- Share local funding with charter schools: Revenues raised through local property tax referenda should be shared proportionately with charter schools residing in the district. Even though state law allows such revenue-sharing to occur, students attending charter schools have been historically excluded from receiving any resources from local taxes. Given that 71% of charter school students are students of color (vs. 19% of district students), restricting charter schools from accessing local tax revenues is exacerbating racial inequities in the state.
ABOUT THE RICHARD M. FAIRBANKS FOUNDATION
The Richard M. Fairbanks Foundation strives to advance the vitality of Indianapolis and the well-being of its people by addressing the city’s most significant challenges and opportunities. The Foundation is focused on three focus areas: education, health and the vitality of Indianapolis. To advance its work, the Foundation implements a three-pronged approach: strategic grantmaking, evidence-based advocacy, and cross-sector collaborations and convenings.
ABOUT THE CENTER ON REINVENTING PUBLIC EDUCATION
Part of the University of Washington Bothell, the Center on Reinventing Public Education is one of the nation’s leading sources for transformative, evidence-based ideas to improve education. To ensure all students are prepared for the future, CRPE puts forward rigorous research and policy analysis to help educators, policymakers, civic and community leaders, parents, and students themselves reimagine education systems and structures.